Saturday, March 6, 2010

Teaching: Business sense for entrepreneurs

KOLKATA: They are just as sharp and focused as some of the youngsters they train. And they could easily have been in their shoes, taking charge of the country's corporate sector. But they have chosen a behind-the-scene role of grooming business leaders, which has also proved to be a lucrative career option for many of these IIM and IIT graduates. Running a CAT coaching centre, they say, could be as rewarding as a multinational job if not more profitable and satisfying. 

Take Naveen Saraff, for instance. The IIM-Bangalore passout quit a job with Reliance Capital in Mumbai to train CAT aspirants at IMS Learning Centre in Kolkata as a franchisee. The reason: he found it as promising and interesting an option as any job that he could land with his IIM degree. "I wanted to be in Kolkata and preferred doing my own thing rather than a regular job. Also, the jobs offered to us on campus were not as lucrative as some of them now are," says Saraff, now the city head of Career Launcher, another CAT training institute. 



Saraff enjoys sharing

his experiences with students and helping them with 

insights and inputs that only an IIM passout can give. "It allowed me to do what I wanted to. I was confident of earning enough," he adds. 

A teaching stint at Time, another leading CAT training institute, changed the course of Rahul Reddy's career. The IIM-Calcutta graduate switched over to teaching entrepreneurship in Kolkata after holding senior posts in MNCs. "The entrepreneurship bug bit me on the IIM campus. I always wanted to be in the education field and try and do things differently. Also, I felt that I could help CAT aspirants do better and help more crack the test," he says. 

Others like Nikunj Bhagat, a partner at Career Launcher, made the switch since it made his professional life more flexible. "Working 12 hours a day and living out of a suitcase was not my idea of happiness. I was better off without the pressure," says Bhagat, an IIM-Bangalore passout. 




With a mechanical engineering degree from IIT-Kanpur and a management diploma from XLRI, Charapreet Singh never really saw himself as a teacher or an entrepreneur till he started teaching CAT aspirants at IMS as a part-time job. Singh, however, didn't take the plunge immediately. After successful stints with Tata Steel, PwC, Compaq and HP, he finally returned to his CAT training job as an entrepreneur. "I have no regrets," says Singh, who now heads the Praxis Business School. 

A growing number of students from leading B-schools across the country are joining management entrance coaching centres. And IIMs are no exception. Last year, two IIM-Ahmedabad students and one from IIM-Indore joined IMS as managers. One from XLRI, Jamshedpur, did the same. 

But are they losing in financial terms to pursue their interest? Yes and no, according to the teacher-entrepreneurs. "Considering the rise in the number of CAT aspirants over the last 10 years, the market has expanded phenomenally. When I started in 1999, around 3000 would take the test from Kolkata," said Saraff. "Now, the number hovers around the 14,000 mark and nearly all of them go through coaching. On the other hand, corporate salaries have gone up manifold. The highest salary offered on campus was around Rs 6 lakh when I passed out. It's five times that figure now. So, at the end of the day it is an individual decision." he adds.

Friday, March 5, 2010

MBA aspirants file RTIs and may move to court

Even as many students got calls from the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) and other business schools for personal interviews and group discussions, many others are upset with their low scores in the Common Admission Test (CAT) and are raising a “transparency” issue with the institutes, besides mulling legal action.

The IIMs were just recovering from the uproar over technical glitches during the CAT. Now, at least five students have filed applications under the Right to Information (RTI) law. More are said to be in the offing. Students that Business Standard spoke to did not wish to be named, but said they are also in discussion with lawyers. More, some IIM professors are said to be lending support to the entire initiative, as they were themselves not happy at the manner the first computer-based CAT had been conducted.

The issue largely revolves around the lack of transparency in the marking scheme and lack of access to details on the test papers. A few faculty members of a test-preparing institute, who also took the CAT exam, said their score was as high as the 90th percentile, though they did not attempt most questions. “We have a team of people who take the exam from our institute. We divide the sections among us and attempt only that. So, many of us just attended one section, but have ended with scores as high as the 86 to 90 percentile. We are sure this has happened to students across the board,” said a faculty member from one such institute. 

“IIM professors have told us to go ahead and file a complaint, as none is coming forward with an explanation on the procedure they used to score us. Besides, Prometric (the agency conducting the test) has also not been helpful in removing our doubts,” said a student, who said he had scored highly in the US-administered Graduate Management Admission Test (GMAT) but not in CAT, “despite it being an easy paper”.


After IIM-Ahmedabad said it had replaced its admission procedure from a point-based system to one with more weightage to class X and XII marks, students have been upset about not having been informed earlier. A CAT candidate said, “It is unfair of IIM-A to change the admission procedure after the results, although they may have the right to do this. The entire CAT 2009 had been a shock for us and this only makes matters worse for us.”

“Many are not happy with the results, as some of them have scored as high as 99.2 per cent in XAT (test for admission to XLRI and XIMB) and only around 96 per cent in CAT and are getting calls from top business schools but not the IIMs. Also, it is unfair for the IIMs to change their admission process at this time,” said Gautam Puri, vice-chairman, Career Launcher.

“We don’t try to search for different permutations and combinations by excluding a particular criterion like Class X or XII scores while screening candidates, as we do not want to come across as biased. Instead, we feed all the pre-requisites of selection criteria into a system and send call letters to all those who fit the eligibility criteria. As for replacing the point-based system of gauging academic performance with a straight 70 per cent score in Class X and XII exams, the move was to simplify the whole process and not discriminate any student,” explained Diptesh Ghosh, chairpersons-admissions of IIM-A, in response to the allegations.

Students, meanwhile, have also written a letter (signed by over 100 students) to the IIMs and faculty members on the issue. “Prior to the CAT examination, IIM authorities had categorically stated that the difficulty levels across papers in a slot were consistently maintained by generating a large number of questions of equal difficulty to establish equivalence; but now have introduced a vague term in the scorecard, ‘Psychometric equivalences’ to adjust for the difficulty levels. There seems to be a contradiction. We students are confused to see such a marking scheme introduced without prior notification before the exam and till now, no explanation has been given from the IIMs or Prometric,” states the letter, among other things.

“It is the right of the candidate to know about the changes in marking scheme, if any, prior to the examination. None of the IIMs or Prometric informed us regarding differential marking. IIMs were following only equal marking all this while. In the absence of the appropriate information regarding the changes in the examination and evaluation pattern, many serious candidates are now in a state of shock and disbelief. At the same time, many low-scoring candidates have expressed their surprise on the high scores,” said a student from Delhi.

“If the IIMs and Prometric are sure of their methodology and calculations, please make the detailed scores of each candidate public. Let there be no doubt in the minds of the students, by making each parameter of CAT 2009 transparent,” asserted another student.

Top consulting firms at IIM Calcutta Placements


Kolkata: Several top consulting firms, including Oliver Wyman Group, McKinsey and Co., Boston Consulting Group, Bain and Co. and Opera Solutions have confirmed their participation in the final placements round at the Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta (IIM-C) starting on Saturday.
US-based Oliver Wyman would be visiting the campus for the first time, said Samyukktha Thirumeni, external relations secretary at the institute.

The Singapore government’s investment arm Temasek Holdings Pte Ltd would be returning to the campus after a year, Thirumeni added. Swiss bank UBS AG has also confirmed participation in slot zero—or the first round of recruitment in which companies hunt for the best talent.

Finance companies such as Bank of America-Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley and Barclays Capital have already offered jobs to students who interned with them during the summer of last year, according to Thirumeni.

These are called pre-placement offers, or PPOs. Last year, IIM-C students received 50 “slot zero PPOs” and 39 job offers in slot zero. With so many finance and consulting firms confirming their participation in slot zero, IIM-C students are expecting much better offers this year, Thirumeni added.

Yet, the institute has like last year decided to keep the placements open-ended, according to Prafulla Agnihotri, professor and chairman of placements at IIM-C.
“We would be placing the biggest batch in IIM-C’s history this year,” he said.

View Source

Thursday, March 4, 2010

IIM-B to refund fees of students opting for NGO placements

The Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore (IIM-B) will refund the fees of around Rs 8 lakh that students pay for their two-year Post Graduate Programme (PGP) if they take up a job in any non-profit entity (NGO) and work there for at least three years.


Students who work in an NGO for a year, too, could get a part-waiver of their fees.
IIM-B officials explained that the decision was taken because a number of students had expressed a desire to work with NGOs over the past few years but were concerned about their finances.
The IIM-B board of governors discussed the issue in a meeting in October 2009 and passed the proposal to take effect for the 2010 placement, starting March 4.

“We want our students to work in NGOs and even the government sector, where there is need for better management,” Pankaj Chandra, director of IIM-B told Business Standard.

The institute believes the move will encourage many of its students to gain a different kind of work experience, simultaneously helping people at the grassroots level.

“We have NGOs like Teach For India and Azim Premji Foundation coming to campus. We have had Narayana Hrudayalaya make a pre-placement talk to students,” said Sapna Agarwal, head of career development services at IIM-B.
The institute declined to explain how it was planning to make good the cost of the fee waiver.

Teach For India, one of the NGOs that made a presentation to final-year students at IIM-B, is looking to recruit students for its two-year Fellowship, which involves placing full-time teachers in low-income schools.

Shveta Raina, national head of fellowship research at Teach For India, said IIM-B’s fee refund was encouraging initiative.
“For two years, our Fellows will get an opportunity to be trained in innovative methods. At the end of the two years, they can avail of our placement services. Companies like McKinsey, Mastek, Thermax and ICICI Bank are interested in hiring from us,” she said.

IIM-B and NGO officials admit that pay-wise, there would be quite a gap in the salaries offered in the corporate and social sector but say the exposure from such programmes would come in handy even if they choose to go back to the corporate sector after a short stint.

For instance, as a fellow at Teach For India, an IIM student could earn around Rs 23,000 a month including stipend, house and classroom allowance whereas companies typically pay IIM freshers between Rs 1 lakh and Rs 1.5 lakh a month.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

XIMB: 100% placements

Bhubaneswar: The Xavier Institute of Management, Bhubaneswar (XIMB), one of the premier B-schools of the country, has announced that all its Post Graduate Diploma in Management (PGDM) and Post Graduate Diploma in Management(Rural Management ) have got placements in Xuberance 2010, the Institution’s annual campus recruitment process. 

“The PGDM batch of 2010 saw an average salary of Rs10.52 lakh per annum, a 45% increase compared to last year," said XIMB director Fr. PT Joseph. With over 27% of the batch receiving pre-placement calls from their summer internship organizations, the momentum of placements continued with over 58 companies participating in the recruitment process. Of these 16% were first time recruiters, he added. 

According to XIMB placement coordinator Kalpesh Kela, Xuberance 10 saw regular recruiters like Cognizant, OLAM International, HCCBPL, Deloitte, UB Group, Vodafone, Infosys, HP, Tata Corp HR, TCS, HSBC, Wipro, Axis Bank, Dr Reddy’s, Essar Group, Societe Generale, ICRA, Tata Steel, Fidelity, Mahindra, Idea, SBI, Tata Tele Services strengthen their relationship with XIMB. New bonds were formed with Nokia, Dell, RBS, Religare, Daimler, Vista Soft, AATCO and many others. The profiles offered varied in their diversity, encompassing corporate finance, equity research, investment banking, marketing, sales and distribution, supply chain management, business consulting, IT consulting, industrial relations and corporate HR. 

The Rural Management Programme of XIMB also witnessed 100% placements this year with all 53 students joining their fields of core competence. The placement week saw the participation of over 20 companies. Some of the star recruiters of this year were ITC, Amul, Mother Dairy, Institute of Financial Management and Research (IFMR), IMRB International, Monsanto India Limited, Manipal Education & Medical group, NASSCOM Foundation, IDBI Bank Ltd etc. 

The highest package of the batch was pegged at Rs 9.5 lakh per annum while the average salary stood at Rs 5.3 lakh per annum . The average salary increased by 18.83% compared to last year’s figures. 

View Source