Saturday, June 19, 2010

ISB Placements rise by 33%

MUMBAI: The 2010 batch of Indian School of Business (ISB), Hyderabad, saw a 33% increase in total number of placement offers and an 11% rise in average salary over last year, the institute said in a media statement.

“This year shows a significant improvement over last year,” said dean Ajit Rangnekar. The class comprising 568 students witnessed offers from top companies in technology, consulting and finance increase by 116%, 40% and 30%, respectively, over the last year, making them the largest recruiters on campus.

Citibank, DBS Bank, Accenture Services, Arthur D. Little Asia, Cognizant Technology Solutions, Amazon Development Centre India, United Health Group and Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories are few of the 346 recruiters.

“Last year was a traumatic year, but we still matched compensation level of 2007,” said Mr Rangnekar. “2008 was a mad year, as companies were paying far too much money. There was gross over optimism in the market. Given that in 2009 there was undue pessimism,” he added.

This year’s highlight was first-time recruiters from the green energy sector like Schneider Electric India and Wipro Eco-business.

View Source

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Foreign MBA degree fetch a Good Job

Due to globalisation, liberalisation and privatisation, it has become feasible to pursue an MBA course from foreign universities especially in UK, Australia, USA and Canada.

Distance learning MBAs and online MBAs from foreign universities still have the same attraction. A foreign degree guarantees more exposure since students need to interact with fellow classmates and faculty to learn and evolve.

In a foreign MBA, students come with work experience in a variety of fields like finance, high-tech, marketing, poetry, films and other such artistic fields. The diversity in student body helps them develop a strong network across all countries.

So does a foreign MBA still have the same attraction as in the past decade? “A foreign MBA degree is still attractive for a large pool of people in India, though only few globally renowned institutes are great to get in, which include Asian Institute of Management, Philippines, London Business School, United Kingdom, Kellogg School of Management, USA, Harvard Business School, USA, and Wharton University of Pennsylvania, USA. One of the good points of a foreign MBA degree is its admission criteria which include 3-4years of corporate experience and case studies which are based on real time experience for students to learn the art of management,” notes Sunil Goel, Director, GlobalHunt, an executive search firm.

Says Jayaram K Iyer, Professor, Marketing, Loyola Institute of Business Administration, “Unfortunately yes and in fact gullible students are falling prey to glitzy advertisements and five-star-hotel fairs from foreign universities that seem to promise more and deliver a lot less; it is as usual the 'country of origin' effect: craze for anything foreign. Most of these foreign universities are here because they can’t find students in their own countries; it is business for them and no education can swerve from altruistic goals. Good foreign MBA degrees are restricted to a few top 30-40 b-schools in the world and the ranks are public information. However, one good aspect of all these foreign MBAs is that, the students get lot more culturally diverse exposure that moulds them to be more global in perspective. Of course, they also become more patriotic realising the worth of India.”

Does a foreign MBA give a better pay, position etc? “A foreign MBA degree from a renowned institute certainly gives better pay and position as it provides exposure, builds up strategic thinking, leadership ability and foremost, it teaches how to get culturally fit in an organisation.

Holding a foreign MBA degree from a renowned institute develops very high aspiration in a candidate as far as compensation is concerned, this might not be feasible in today's economic scenario,” adds Goel.

So the question is, Is a foreign MBA essential to fetch a good job? “Finally, one needs to decide what he/she plans to do after an MBA. This is probably the most defining factor to take a decision. If one is planning to take up a job abroad, one can opt for a foreign MBA. If one plans to return to India on completion, one should think through. Compared to foreign B-schools, Indian institutions offer cost advantage, making them more attractive if one is planning to build one’s career in India,” feels Ajay Oberoi, director general & trustee, AICAR Business School.

The quality of education at top-ranked Indian business schools is at par with some of the best in the world. But that applies to only a handful of business schools across the country.

In India, most of the MBA students are fresh out of college and have no work experience. This is not the case with the foreign MBA institutions.

Students come with work experience in a variety of areas and this helps them broaden their perspective. Whatever the route, a foreign MBA degree from a renowned institute certainly enhances one’s chances of fetching a good job and gives one an edge over other candidates.

View Source    

Monday, May 24, 2010

Management Education Flaws

It is tragic that education today churns out graduates unmindful of the requirements of the industry that will employ them. In boom times, most organisations grab whatever employee they can and then invest heavily in training, for want of an alternative. We have heard of the training campuses of large companies. I was involved in training for new recruits at Lehman Brothers when they set up their back office in Mumbai. 

Also, an investment banker was in discussion with me once to set up a mini-university within his company. The objective: crash the time it takes a new recruit to be productive, from nine months to 45 days. 

No depth

The problem with our management education is fundamental. Most MBA courses, for example, are marketed on the basis of a stated number of credit courses. Some are compulsory while others are elective. Each credit course on paper is well laid out with quizzes, presentations, assignments, reading and end-term examination. The process of evaluation is expected to assign marks for class participation as well.

So, topics like elements of finance and derivatives may each have one course. Naturally, a more complex subject like derivatives takes a beating, having to be covered in a short time-span. Before a faculty can warm up to the subject and establish rapport with the students, the course is over and finished. There is neither an effort nor a desire to grill the students in the fundamentals and ingrain some depth of knowledge such that when he enters employment, he is ready to contribute.

In my interactions with students undergoing super-specialisation in different aspects of finance such as wealth management or investment banking, it was appalling to see them struggling with basics. What is their specialisation and what is super about them is anybody’s guess. In most of these institutes, we still have the concept of a teacher coming and lecturing, students taking down copious notes and later regurgitating the same in an end-term exam, passing with marks upwards of 90% but with little assimilation of knowledge. The institutes have learnt to avoid investments in libraries and the tech-savvy students, heavily reliant on Googling, have adjusted very well, rarely making visits there. They all want handouts, for reading multiple books is an activity for which they have no time. 

Education is viewed as a very profitable business, where your cash flow is upfront before the product is delivered, and admission is driven not by quality of education but by placement and remuneration record. Higher the placement record, better the average pay offered, greater the intake of students. The institutions are structured to cater to this formula. They use marketing skills and personal relationships with HR managers and somehow push placement for the students. Many even dump a certain syllabus on the students, make them learn a few jargons and unleash them in the market to wreak havoc. Most students in finance would have no clue on any practical aspect of what they learn. 

They don’t get to see a Reuters or Bloomberg screen, rarely visit active markets during the course — all this despite the internet and other trappings of modernity being available. In fact, most teachers themselves must be surviving without actually visiting the live markets.

No exposure


What is taught is determined by the academicians who rule these institutions and not on the basis of what the recruiter would like to have. While some do invite practising professionals to come as visiting faculty, that exposure is minimal. Rare are those institutions who invite practitioners on a professional basis to conduct a full-credit course with complete practical orientation. 

The general approach ingrained in the average MBA course seems to be that the students need to have a broad overview of the various subjects and not necessarily in-depth knowledge in any sub-topic. This has reduced it to a farce, with the students throwing sophisticated phrases with little understanding of concepts. You scratch them at the surface and they start to falter. I have seen this at different levels in different situations. 

Students in finance complete the course without a clue on how products are structured or traded, why the arbitrage taught in a classroom rarely works in practice, how bid-offer spreads and liquidity can kill all that theory mugged up in a classroom. The pity is that most don’t care, so long as there is a job at the end of the course. 


Low-paid teachers

Emmanuele Darman describes this in his book My Life as a Quant: “During my last few years at Goldman Sachs, I interviewed undergraduates applying for jobs in investment banking, and I was often surprised at how little of their coursework some of them recalled, how little a sense they had of the essence of their field. I met juniors majoring in statistics who couldn’t define standard deviation and students who had taken several courses in electromagnetic theory but couldn’t remember Maxwell’s equation. What I had learned, I had learned well. Theirs’ sometimes seemed a wasted education.”
 
Rarely is teaching a choice of pursuing a passion. While there are some faculty members who have opted for it despite the low remuneration, in most cases, it is by default. I have never been able to reconcile the expectations from low-paid faculty members who turn out students offered starting salaries higher than their remuneration. Rarely do you find practising managers giving up their lucrative careers to teach.


Industry’s role

Institutions trying to attract visiting faculty from practising managers also face many problems. They owe their loyalty to the organisation they work for, cancel lectures at the last minute, and rarely coordinate the topics or deliver to the agreed syllabus. To make matters worse, these visiting managers rarely read and hence fail to stitch the theory to the practice. 
 
While the brochures speak elegantly about the faculty, pedagogy with lectures, case studies, class discussion, etc, it is seen that faculty often don’t change the case studies for more than 4-5 years. Even today, most institutions would harp on the Barings case study, while there are multiple cases of later years available to emphasise on the learning. Latest market practices are often not taught. For instance, a class on fixed income markets would rarely refer to the FIMMDA or its handbook of market practices, CCIL and the clearing and settlement practices, RBI’s electronic anonymous screen-based trading system and how to interpret the market from the prices quoted there, etc. It is possible that in most cases the faculty themselves are not aware of these. 

It is necessary to deal with this on a holistic basis. Initiative must come from industry to set up state-of-the-art management training institutes. Each one can be set up by a cluster of contributing or participating companies. Each of these institutes must have a cluster of real businesses, producing products and services used by the participating companies setting up the institution. Students studying for an MBA would spend 3-4 years with a well-structured mixture of theory and practice. The companies must be run by the students themselves with assistance from faculty who must be practising managers. 

Graduates must be assured of jobs from the participating companies with an option to choose jobs outside the participating companies. By the time they graduate, they would have managed different aspects of a running company and be ready to put their theory to practice, having dabbled in it. 

This is possible only if organisations such as FICCI, CII and Assocham take the lead and set up great centres of learning across the country. The faculty should be paid on the same scales as senior management staff in industry. Naturally, the cost of such education would be high and must be borne by the students, through scholarships if necessary. Needless to say, for their work in running the company, they will be paid a remuneration which can partially defray the cost of their education. 

If we fail to address the need to revamp our education system and think innovatively, managing double-digit growth rates may be an uphill task.

Saturday, April 10, 2010

B-schools and entrepreneurship

Entrepreneurship is becoming a popular career choice these days among aspirants and in an endeavour to cater to this growing demand, many institutions are making ‘entrepreneurship education’ a part of their curriculum. ET HighFlier discusses the unique ways business schools are adopting to support students who have a penchant towards creating something new.

MENTORING ENTREPRENEURS:

Karam Lakshman, program manager - iAccelerator, IIMAhmedabad believes that entrepreneurship education seeks to provide students with the knowledge, skills and motivation required to encourage entrepreneurial success and lay down the conditions and solutions to the challenges that one might foresee in a venture. “Business is the backbone of a country’s economy and entrepreneurship is a tremendous force that has a huge impact on facilitating growth, recovery and societal progress. It results in innovation, employment generation and social empowerment. In India, entrepreneurship education is gradually picking up. That said, it needs to scale up further to make everyone involved – promoter, investor, parents, employees, etc - more aware about the different aspects,” he expresses.

“The time is right for the educated managers to stop looking for jobs and start providing them to others. Forming the right team is one of the challenges that an entrepreneur faces and if a person is starting early while he/she is in college, they will find the right kind of people amongst their friends, who they can work with easily,” he asserts.

“Students work on their own business plan as part of a project. The students get an opportunity to do projects with the incubates. This helps them achieve a handson experience of working with a start-up .” Lakshman adds.

Lakshman further says, “We will soon be competing with the best in the world if you compare statistics on number of start-ups, funding, etc. Entrepreneurs who don’t know how to go about it, here’s a pearl of wisdom: An entrepreneurial journey is like travelling through a thin fog when there is no wind. Start walking and it will keep getting clearer ahead. If you try and wait to get a complete picture from the start itself , you will keep waiting. Just take the first step and keep walking.”

GROOMING ENTREPRENEURS:

According to Dr Harsh Mishra, associate professor, strategic management , Management Development Institute (MDI), Gurgaon, there is a need for B-schools to have entrepreneurship focused courses and programs. “Before even experiencing the status quo as an employee, formal education in entrepreneurship makes a case for early intervention by exposing students to successful stories, the underlying rationale or theory as well as the science and mechanism for tapping and developing their entrepreneurial instincts,” says Mishra.

Many organisations offers fullcredit courses in entrepreneurship and are also establishing a business incubator that could provide the opportunity to several new entrepreneurs to germinate their ideas into a business enterprise. According to Mishra, courses and programs on entrepreneurship are often interdisciplinary and an MBA program with entrepreneurial focus encourages students to crystallise, test, self-critique and gain confidence in their own ideas to move forward.

Many experts feel that B-schools must encourage entrepreneurship, but a student before opting for such courses, must analyse his/her own personal entrepreneurial capacity. Before starting up a venture, one must evaluate their entrepreneurial idea to meet the existing market need or a new emerging market demand, become aware of the legalities involved and various support systems in the eco-system for entrepreneurship and must not be obsessed with the desired financial outcome.

NURTURING ENTREPRENEURS:

Prof S Sadagopan, director, IIITBangalore feels that knowledge and wealth creation are equally important . He is of the belief that Bschools must encourage entrepreneurship , period. “We promote both, a formal as well as an informal program. Within 10 years of existence, we have incubated four successful companies. Currently, we are incubating five companies. The proof of the pudding is in eating; more than 20 of our alumni are pursuing new ventures currently,” he shares. Talking about the future of this rising trend of entrepreneurship education, Sadagopan says, “It is clear. Indian techies will increasingly look at e-option ! The eco-system is taking shape. My advice to entrepreneurs is to get into the ‘network’ and benefit from the huge advantage.”

Starting one’s own venture is never an easy task but a formal training could teach a person the nuances of the journey. That is why entrepreneurship education is gaining such momentum in recent times.

View Source

Thursday, April 8, 2010

NITIE Placements 2010

Mumbai-based National Institute of Industrial Engineering (NITIE) has registered the highest domestic pay package of Rs 19.5 lakh a year and highest international pay package of Rs 67.5 lakh a year during its final placements.

The international placements were offered by companies like Olam International and Dubai Telecom. 

Around 90 companies participated in the placement process, offering roles in domains like supply chain, operations, marketing, finance, consulting and information technology (IT) & systems. 

Companies like Procter & Gamble, Cadbury, GE, Essar, L’Oreal, Cummins among others made pre-placement offers (PPOs), with 25 students accepting the direct route to their dream jobs. 

Other recruiters who participated in the placement process include players like PwC, Ernst and Young, Cognizant Business Consulting, Global e-Procure, Bristlecone, Capgemini, Citibank, HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank, JPMC, Deutsche Bank, GE, ICICI Bank, YES Bank, SBI Caps and Kotak Mahindra. The profiles offered were investment banking, corporate finance, bank operations, retail banking etc. 

Meanwhile, the institute also completed summer placements for 2011, with Cadbury offering the highest stipend of Rs 1 lakh for a two-month internship. 

The summer placements for the 2009-11 batch of NITIE attracted companies like Ernts and Young, KPMG, Cognizant Business Consulting, PWC, Citibank, HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank, Deutsche Bank, ICICI Bank, Edelweiss, Bank of India, Axis bank, Union Bank of India among others. 

HSBC offered internships to seven students, the highest for any one company in the banking and financial sector.